BUSINESS
The Biscuit Tax France Buried Is Back in the Senate
Deputies struck out France’s processed food tax at 86 to 58, then killed the whole bill, sending the biscuit levy back to senators who are keeping it.
A France processed food tax on biscuits and cakes is back in the Senate after deputies struck it out 86 to 58 on 22 October. They rejected the whole social-security bill the next day, which erased that deletion and restored the government’s original Article 8.
Health minister Stéphanie Rist had told the house the levy was a recipe tool, not a till shock, at less than eight euro cents on a pack of cookies. Senators opened the floor on 9 November with sittings listed through 18 November, and their social-affairs commission has already voted to keep the tax while cutting out artisans and French origin labels.
After the 86-58 Vote, the Whole Bill Fell
Article 8 of the 2027 Social Security Financing Bill, tabled on 1 October, extended the existing soda levy to pre-packed sweet solids. On 22 October the National Assembly adopted cross-party deletion amendments, 86 to 58 with 3 abstentions. Deputies from Droite Républicaine and the National Rally voted as a bloc to strike it. MoDem, LFI, the Socialists, the Greens and LIOT voted to keep it. Horizons and the presidential EPR group split, and EPR’s own amendment 2792 was among those adopted.
That win lasted one sitting. On 23 October the house rejected the receipts part of the bill by 115 votes to 1, with 22 abstentions, recorded as T.A. n° 358. Under the finance-bill rules, a failed receipts vote kills the text. Every amendment made in the Assembly, including the biscuit-tax deletion, fell with it.
The National Assembly file on the 2027 bill now shows first reading as rejected, with the Senate seized on 2 November of projet n° 138, the government’s original copy. Article 8 is in that copy. The solemn vote once listed for 27 October never happened.
HOW ARTICLE 8 FELL AND CAME BACK
- 1 October 2026: The government deposits the PLFSS for 2027, with Article 8 extending the soda levy to packed sweet foods from 1 January 2027.
- 14 October 2026: The Assembly social-affairs commission keeps the extension and widens it toward ultra-processed products that list additives.
- 22 October 2026: The house deletes Article 8 by 86 votes to 58.
- 23 October 2026: Deputies reject the receipts section 115 to 1. The whole bill is treated as rejected and the deletion dies with it.
- 4 November 2026: Senate social affairs, reporting as n° 144, keeps the levy and carves out artisans and French quality-origin labels.
- 9 November 2026: Floor debate opens, with further sittings listed on 12, 13, 14, 16, 17 and 18 November.
A joint committee of seven deputies and seven senators would have to seek a common text after the Senate votes. The Assembly would still have the last word if that talks fail.
Eight Cents on a Pack of Cookies
Rist’s eight-cent line was the government’s answer to the till argument, and it sits on a small official scale. The levy is not a single rate. It is a three-tier levy of 4.07, 14 and 22 euros per 100 kg, which is €4.07, €14 or €22 per quintal, indexed each January to consumer prices excluding tobacco. The cap of €22 ($24.6) per 100 kg is 22 cents per kilogram.
Three tests all have to be met. The food must be pre-packed, it must contain sugars (added or not) at 10 g or more per 100 g, and the ingredient list must name at least one additive. Loose bakery counter cakes stay out. So do packs under the sugar floor.
THE RATES IN ARTICLE 8
| Product family | Lower band | Middle band | Top band |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cereals, biscuits, ice cream | 10 to 23 g/100 g at €4.07 | 23 to 30 g at €14 | 30 g and up at €22 |
| Confectionery and chocolate | 10 to 47 g/100 g at €4.07 | 47 to 56 g at €14 | 56 g and up at €22 |
A parallel charge on synthetic sweeteners, €4.50 to €6 per 100 kg, would have applied to the same packs if makers swapped sugar for intense sweeteners instead of cutting sweetness. The Institut de liaisons des entreprises de consommation, which briefed brand owners, said the charge would stack and rise with inflation.
THE SIX FAMILIES IN THE DRAFT
- Confectionery: Sweets and related packed sugar goods under the customs heading used for sugar confectionery.
- Chocolate: Chocolate and chocolate products, including bars, taxed on a higher sugar grid than biscuits.
- Breakfast cereals: Packed cereals and cereal bars above 10 g of sugars per 100 g.
- Biscuits and cakes: Industrial biscuits, cakes and viennoiseries sold in packs, not by the slice at a bakery counter.
- Ice cream: Pre-packed ice cream on the same grid as cereals and biscuits.
- Flour and dairy mixes: Some packed preparations classed under CN 1901 90 99, which is why dairy groups asked the Senate to pull that code out.
Jean-François Loiseau, president of the food-industry body ANIA, said consumers would be the ones who pay. ILEC put food makers’ net margin at 3.5%, against 5.8% for manufacturing as a whole, citing a Banque de France reading of 13,533 firms, and said nearly one in three food SMEs is in deficit. Those figures describe a tight margin. They do not, on the official scale, describe a levy that could move a typical biscuit pack by more than small change unless a maker passed through the top band in full.
Why a Farm Health Fund Sat in the Fine Print
The government scored the extension at about €300 million a year and earmarked it for the health branch of the agricultural social scheme, which covers farm operators and farm workers. That assignment is easy to miss in a fight about cookie prices, and it is the part of the design that makes the levy a farm-health receipt rather than a general budget plug.
MSA’s own 2027 charges-and-products note shows how thin that branch’s own take is. For non-salaried farmers, professional funding (contributions plus CSG) was about €1.0 billion in 2025, 15.3% of health-branch receipts, with more than €3.0 billion coming as transfers from the general scheme. For farm employees, professional funding was about €3.2 billion, 44.4% of receipts. A €300 million assigned tax is small beside those transfers. It is not small beside a branch that already leans on the general regime.
THE LEVY IN THREE FIGURES
- Government yield: About €300 million a year, assigned to farm health cover, not to the general state budget.
- Rist’s pack line: Less than eight euro cents on a pack of cookies if the maker does not cut sugar.
- Industry margin: 3.5% net in food, against 5.8% in manufacturing, per the Banque de France sample ILEC cited.
Opposing deputy Justine Gruet said the levy would “reduce the purchasing power of our citizens without actually affecting their eating habits or sugar consumption.” She added: “In short, yes to prevention, yes to nutrition education within the family unit, but no to new taxes that will not solve the problem.” That is the argument that carried 22 October. It is also the argument that did not survive 23 October, because the same majority that disliked new taxes disliked the rest of the receipts title enough to throw the whole bill out.
Rist Cited a UK Cut France Did Not Repeat
Rist told the house the progressive tax “aims to encourage manufacturers to reduce the amount of sugar in their recipes.” She said 40 rounds of voluntary talks with processors had not produced firm commitments. She also said 80% of children now consume more sugar than the maximum, and the government presentation put the rise in processed-food consumption at 170% since the 1980s.
The tax, which is progressive, aims to encourage manufacturers to reduce the amount of sugar in their recipes.
Stéphanie Rist, health minister, National Assembly
She pointed to the United Kingdom’s drinks levy and cited a 46% drop in sugar in UK soft drinks between 2015 and 2020. That 46% figure is hers. A BMC Medicine analysis of 2015 to 2018 found the sales-weighted mean sugar content of UK soft drinks fell from 4.4 g to 2.9 g per 100 ml, with the volume of sugars sold down about 29 to 30%. The UK official sugar-reduction progress report tracks that drinks levy separately from the slower voluntary programme on solid foods, which never hit its 20% sugar-cut aim by 2020.
France already taxes sodas. A flat levy arrived in January 2012. In July 2018 it was rebuilt as a sliding charge on added sugar, the model Article 8 copies onto solids. A 2023 comparison in the European Journal of Public Health found the 2018 French redesign cut average sugar in new sugary soft drinks by 6% in 2018 against 2017, with no significant further cut in 2019, while the UK levy produced much larger yearly drops after it was announced. A Senate health-tax note on the French drinks charge called the effect on household sugar from taxed sodas marginal, about 29.7 g per household per month, and counted 69 downward recipe changes from 2014 to 2019, 12% of the taxed drinks.
Drinks are easier to rebuild than biscuits. Water, sweetener and flavour can replace sugar in a bottle without collapsing the product. A biscuit needs bulk, browning and snap. Copying a drinks tax onto packed cakes was always a harder mechanical transfer than the UK comparison made it sound, and France’s own drinks record was already thinner than the British one Rist put on the record.
Senate Commission Kept the Levy and Cut Out Nougat
Olivier Henno’s social-affairs commission at the Senate, reporting on 4 November, did not repeat the Assembly’s deletion. The Senate social affairs commission report keeps Article 8 and excludes artisanal products and products with a French official quality and origin sign. The fiscal cost of that cut is scored NS, not significant. The commission adopted 76 amendments and said measures that worsened the 2027 balance by €2 billion were offset by €2 billion of savings, leaving the government’s €12.7 billion deficit target intact against a 2026 outturn put at €21.8 billion.
That carve-out is where the health logic and the industrial politics part company. Nougat de Montélimar and other SIQO lines can be as sweet as a supermarket biscuit. The commission’s test is who made them and under which label, not only how many grams of sugar sit in 100 g. Two packs with the same sugar can then face different bills, one because it is industrial and additive-listed, the other because it carries an origin mark or was packed at the shop. A levy sold as a recipe signal becomes, at the margin, a tax on factory brands.
Some processors had already said a binding rule would be useful. The split inside the trade is not only ANIA versus the ministry. Firms that have already cut sugar benefit if rivals are forced onto the same ladder. Firms at 3.5% net margin, with no easy recipe change left, do not. Public-health groups, including the patients’ union France Assos Santé, had written to MPs in October telling them not to let industry veto a prevention tool.
WHAT WE KNOW
- Legal status: Article 8 is in the government text the Senate is reading, after the Assembly’s deletion fell with the bill on 23 October.
- Commission text: Senators on social affairs kept the levy and exempted artisans and French SIQO products, with the yield cut scored NS.
- Calendar: Floor debate opened 9 November and is listed through 18 November.
WHAT IS UNCONFIRMED
- Final scope: Dairy-code and added-sugar-only amendments are still on the Senate paper and have not been adopted in public session.
- Final yield: The €300 million farm-health figure is the government’s score for the original Article 8, not for a SIQO-stripped version.
- Enactment: A joint committee, a second Assembly reading, and the organic 50-day clock all still sit in front of any 1 January 2027 start.
Commerce minister Serge Papin, a former supermarket chief, had said before the bill dropped that he was not “for taxes” and still backed a health case, using the line that a nine-year-old has already eaten as much sugar as a grandfather did in a lifetime. The Economic, Social and Environmental Council had backed a move only with reservations, wanting mandatory nutrition targets written first and a tax held for products that missed a collective deadline. Parliament never wrote that sequence. It wrote a small sliding levy, deleted it, then sent the first version back to the Luxembourg Palace.
Biscuits, Additives and the Artisan Line
The additive test is doing as much work as the sugar bands. A packed cake with 12 g of sugars per 100 g and no listed additive would have been out. A packed cake with the same sugars and one authorised colour or emulsifier would have been in. That is a factory test more than a dessert test, and it is why artisan bakers and origin labels became the pressure valves in both houses. MoDem deputy Cyrille Isaac-Sibille tried in the Assembly to push the other way, stretching the charge to all ultra-processed packs that list additives, including so-called hidden sugars, whatever the customs code. Commission deputies also voted to spare small food firms. The Senate commission kept the spare-the-artisan instinct and added the SIQO door.
Retailers are already moving on additives without waiting for a French legal definition of ultra-processed food, including own-brand rules that already cut additives. Article 8 would have used the EU additives list as a tax tripwire rather than as a shelf standard. That is a different tool. It prices the recipe instead of pulling the ingredient. It also leaves a clean pack of high-sugar jam or an origin nougat on a lighter bill than a supermarket sponge that names an emulsifier.
ANIA had warned that suppliers had “reached the limit of their resilience.” The Fédération des entreprises de boulangerie called the plan a stab in the back while its members worked on a collective sugar-cut accord for pastry and viennoiserie. Chocolate, confectionery and biscuit federations called it an economic, industrial and territorial fault that would hit family firms in the regions. Those lines treated the levy as a payroll event. On the published bands, it is a quintal event. The political conversion of 22 cents a kilo into a cost-of-living story is what carried the 86-58 vote. The conversion of that vote into a durable kill is what failed on 23 October.
Senators still have to finish the receipts title, then the rest of the bill, before any joint committee meets. The levy deputies buried on 22 October is the text they are amending, with nougat already walking and industrial biscuits still in scope.
-
NEWS3 months agoGeneration Lab’s Secret Youth Shot Has a Copycat Problem
-
AUTO3 months agoTesla Raises Dual Motor Prices as Texas Builds Cybercabs
-
LIFESTYLE3 months agoThe Nantucket Friendship Basket Boom Meets a Maker Shortage
-
NEWS3 months agoOkta Stock Jumps 20% on McKinnon’s Identity Bet
-
BUSINESS3 months agoBristol Myers Quits Cellares as Autoimmune Doses Proceed
-
BUSINESS3 months agoPoland Closes Visa-Free Work for Three Fast-Growing Nationalities
-
LIFESTYLE3 months agoLabor Day Mattress Sales Repeat a Familiar Holiday Discount
-
NEWS3 months agoGoogle Ends EU Spam Demotions but Keeps the Ranking Split
