Connect with us

NEWS

The Bears Pay Two Firsts for Jeffery Simmons Again

Chicago sent two first-round picks to Tennessee for Jeffery Simmons, repeating its 2018 Khalil Mack wager, and is 7-2 after his first two games.

Published

on

The Chicago Bears sent two first-round picks to Tennessee for All-Pro defensive tackle Jeffery Simmons on Oct. 29, then won both of his first two games. Chicago is 7-2, first in the NFC North, and on a Week 10 bye after a 27-24 win over Tampa Bay in which he sacked the quarterback for the second straight week.

The price is the same one this franchise paid for Khalil Mack in 2018. Simmons is 29, already paid like the highest-priced interior lineman in the league, and under contract through 2030. Two games do not close that ledger. They do show why general manager Ryan Poles made the call.

Two First-Round Picks for a Defensive Tackle

Chicago announced the deal on Oct. 29: the club sent its 2027 and 2028 first-round picks and a 2027 fourth-round choice to the Titans for Simmons and a 2028 fifth. No Super Bowl-era team had traded two first-round picks for a defensive tackle until this one.

Simmons, listed at 6-foot-4 and 305 pounds, was the 19th overall pick in 2019 out of Mississippi State, where he lined up with current Bears end Montez Sweat. He started 104 of 106 regular-season games in Tennessee, made four Pro Bowls, and was a first-team All-Pro in 2025 after a career-high 11 sacks and 17 tackles for loss, both tops among interior linemen. The Bears’ release also credited him with 72 tackles for loss for his career at the time of the trade. He wears No. 99 in Chicago.

THE PICKS THAT MOVED

Club Sent Received
Bears 2027 first, 2028 first, 2027 fourth Simmons, 2028 fifth
Titans Simmons, 2028 fifth 2027 first, 2028 first, 2027 fourth

Poles had spent months hunting a disruptor up front. Chicago wanted Mack back from the Chargers, who would not engage, and it chased Indianapolis tackle DeForest Buckner before San Francisco took him back for a fourth-round pick. Simmons was the one who actually moved, and he moved only when Poles put two firsts on the table.

Through seven Titans games he had 4 sacks and 38 tackles, played 86.6 percent of the defensive snaps, and led all tackles with 28 quarterback pressures, per NFL Next Gen Stats. He won 27 percent of his pass-rush snaps, first among defensive tackles, and still saw double teams on 84 percent of those rushes.

Chicago Has Run This Play Before

On Sept. 1, 2018, the Bears sent the Raiders first-round picks in 2019 and 2020, plus a 2019 sixth and a 2020 third, for Mack, a 2020 second (tight end Cole Kmet) and a 2020 seventh. Hours later they signed Mack to a six-year, $141 million deal with $90 million guaranteed, then the highest pay for a defensive player. It was the first time in nine years a veteran had been traded for multiple first-round picks, and the first time a veteran defender had gone for that price since 1988. Chicago had also mailed two firsts to Denver for quarterback Jay Cutler in 2009.

Mack gave them 12.5 sacks in 2018 and a defense that carried a 12-4 team. The Raiders turned the 2019 first into running back Josh Jacobs at No. 24 and the 2020 first into cornerback Damon Arnette at No. 19. The Bears reached the playoffs with Mack and did not win a postseason game in those years. He later left. The argument around that trade never really died, because two firsts for a non-quarterback is a bet that the player in the building beats the players you will not draft.

THE 2018 MACK DEAL AND THIS ONE

Item Mack, 2018 Simmons, 2026
Age at the trade 27 29
Picks Chicago sent Two firsts, a third, a sixth Two firsts, a fourth
Picks Chicago got back A second and a seventh A fifth
New money Six years, $141 million Already extended through 2030
Year-one sacks in Chicago 12.5 2.0 in two games

Simmons is two years older than Mack was, and he plays inside, where careers can last longer and the market is thinner. He also arrived with the contract already done, which is the piece of this rerun that is not a copy of 2018.

Two Sacks and a First-Place Bye

Simmons debuted on Nov. 2 in Seattle and the Bears won 34-17. He had 6 tackles, a sack and a pass breakup. Six days later, on Nov. 8 against Tampa Bay, Chicago won 27-24 on Cairo Santos’s 38-yard kick as time expired. Simmons had 4 tackles, another sack and another breakup. Caleb Williams threw four interceptions and the offense turned the ball over five times. The defense posted four sacks and two interceptions, including Jaylon Johnson’s 67-yard pick-six, and Simmons was one of the four sack men, with Austin Booker, Shemar Turner and a split between Grady Jarrett and Daniel Hardy.

SIMMONS IN A BEARS UNIFORM

  • Seattle, Nov. 2: 6 tackles, 1 sack, 1 pass breakup in a 34-17 win.
  • Tampa Bay, Nov. 8: 4 tackles, 1 sack, 1 pass breakup in a 27-24 win.
  • Chicago total: 10 tackles and 2 sacks in 2 games, both wins.
  • 2026 season: 6.0 sacks and 48 tackles in 9 games after 4 sacks in 7 starts for Tennessee.

The Bears are 7-2, their best nine-game start since they were also 7-2 in 2012, with four straight wins and a Week 10 bye. They sit first in the NFC North and second in the conference behind the 7-1 49ers. The defense has 26 sacks, third in the league, and has had at least two in every game. At the moment of the trade, Austin Mock’s projection model moved Chicago’s playoff odds from 73 percent to 77 percent. The standings have moved faster than that model did.

League tracking now lists him with 48.5 sacks in 108 games. The two in Chicago are a small sample. They are also a sack in each win, which is the start Poles paid for.

Why the 2026 Cap Hit Is $7.9 Million

Simmons signed a three-year, $105.8 million extension through 2030 with Tennessee on June 19, a $35.3 million average that passed Chris Jones’s $31.75 million mark and made him the highest-paid defensive tackle in the league. The deal carries $100 million in guarantees, with $60.2 million fully guaranteed at signing and a $20 million signing bonus the Titans had already paid. Chicago owes him $7.9 million against the 2026 cap.

That is the quiet half of the price. Two first-round picks dominate the argument. The cash this season does not, because Tennessee structured the new years with a bonus it had to eat. Spotrac’s ledger still charges the Titans $14.1 million in 2026 dead money and $20.8 million in 2027, and it has them down for $25.3 million paid for seven games. Chicago’s hits rise fast after this year.

SIMMONS CAP HITS IN CHICAGO

Year Cap hit Note
2026 $7.9 million Bonus already paid by Tennessee
2027 $22.6 million Compensation still guaranteed
2028 $30.9 million Fully guarantees on the fifth league day of 2027
2029 $29.1 million $10 million already on an injury guarantee
2030 $33.1 million Club can exit with no dead money

Poles said the four years after 2026 were the point of the forecasting. “You want to make sure that you’re not hurting the organization long term just to have short-term gain,” he said. “And that’s where Jeffery Simmons’ contract comes into play, where you have four additional years after this, so you really feel like you can continue to build your football team while helping in the short term.”

Tennessee Banks Nine Picks in 2027

Titans controlling owner Amy Adams Strunk put the goodbye in writing. “There are few people like Jeff Simmons,” she said. “We are forever grateful for all he has given this team and this city. His formidable presence on the field was surpassed only by what he did off it.”

General manager Mike Borgonzi, who worked with Poles in Kansas City from 2009 through 2021, said he had not been shopping Simmons. The Bears called on the night of Oct. 28. “He’s really the only person who came out and said, ‘Would you accept this?’” Borgonzi said. Tennessee was 1-6. “You have to be real with where you’re at when you look at the team and how are we going to be better next year, the year and the year after,” he said. “You’re always looking at a three-year window with a roster in terms of guys under contract. We felt like this was the best decision moving forward for us, as hard as it is, to really accelerate that process.”

The Titans are 1-7. The 2027 draft order entering Week 10 has the 0-8 Chargers at No. 1, Tennessee at No. 2 and the 1-7 Dolphins at No. 3. After also moving safety Amani Hooker, Tennessee holds nine selections in that draft, including two firsts and two seconds. Chicago’s first-rounder, tied to a 7-2 club, currently sits near the bottom of the round.

TENNESSEE’S 2027 PICKS

  • First round: Own pick, plus the Bears’ first.
  • Second round: Own pick, plus a pick from Buffalo.
  • Middle rounds: Own third, own fourth, plus the Bears’ fourth.
  • Late rounds: Own sixth and seventh; the fifth went to Buffalo in the Hooker deal.

Across 2027 and 2028 the Titans now hold four first-round picks. That is the other half of the Mack pattern. Oakland used Chicago’s firsts on Jacobs and Arnette. Borgonzi still has to turn this pile into a roster around quarterback Cam Ward.

A Late-Night Call From Ryan Poles

Poles said he had not expected Tennessee to move a player that central. “I know how much he means to that organization, so I honestly didn’t think it would ever happen,” he said. “When that window kinda opened where it was a possibility, and then had to work their process as well, it happened pretty fast. It was a late call and it happened in the early morning.”

You do this type of move when you have a combination of impact player on the grass as well as someone that can enhance your culture. I don’t think it can be either/or when you talk about a move of this size. You need to have both and that’s what Jeffery does.

Ryan Poles, Bears general manager, Oct. 30 press availability

He called Simmons an impact player on the grass and a standard-setter who “makes it a little bit uncomfortable for you” when the building slips. The two men had eyes on each other at a joint practice in Nashville on Aug. 27. Poles also leaned on a 12-year Chiefs scouting friendship. “Mike is a guy that I have known for a long time, probably in this business someone I have worked with longer than anybody,” he said.

Coach Ben Johnson called Simmons one of the most respected players in the league and “one of the most impactful run defenders and disruptive pass-rushers.” Bengals center Ted Karras, preparing to face Tennessee after the deal, put him in the top three at the position and said the trade “makes them pretty serious.”

Simmons heard the same thing in the pick package. “The trade told me everything I needed to know, especially the value from giving away two first-round picks,” he said. He said he could dwell on being moved, or he could see that “this team believes in what they have here and they want it right now.”

The Window Caleb Williams Is Playing In

Poles tied the swing to Johnson’s staff and to Williams, who is still on a rookie contract. “Tremendous amount of belief in our head coach and coaching staff. You don’t [trade for Simmons] if [you] don’t have that,” Poles said. “A lot of hope and belief in our quarterback and that path he’s on as well.” He also pushed back on the joke about throwing picks away. “That’s really not what we’re about,” he said. “I know it took a lot to get this done, but we absolutely believe that the draft and bringing young talent is a way that you sustain success around here. I’m challenging myself and our crew that for the picks that we do have, we have to hit.”

The Bears still have to hit those later picks, and they still have not won in the NFC North. They are 0-2 in the division after a 3-9 loss to Minnesota and a 7-31 loss at Green Bay, which is the hole sitting under a 7-2 record. They host the Saints on Nov. 22, then go to Detroit on Thanksgiving.

Mack’s version of this trade bought a great defender, a 12-4 season and no playoff win. Simmons has two sacks, two wins and four years of cap football still to play. The Bears paid the same kind of price they paid in 2018. The next two months decide whether this copy ends in the same place.

Harry is the editor of COVER 365, an independent publication he owns and runs, and a journalist of ten years who moved from reporting into editing. Anything the site reviews has been used before it is judged. A phone, a car, a game or a piece of travel gear is tested in ordinary conditions, its measured results are set against the maker's specification sheet, and where the two disagree the article says which one to trust and why. No product gets a verdict Harry has not earned by using it. Off the test bench, the same rule of primary evidence applies: business stories come from filings and results, science from the published paper, sports from the governing body's records, and news from statements and transcripts rather than second hand accounts. Coverage runs across technology, auto, gaming, lifestyle and travel as well as news, business, science, sports and entertainment, for readers in every part of the world. Every figure is checked before publication and corrected publicly under a stated policy when wrong. Reader mail is answered at support@cover365.in.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending