Connect with us

GAMING

The Digital Fairness Act Makes PEGI 16 a Kids Flag

The Digital Fairness Act names PEGI ratings as a kids-product test, so paid loot boxes in teen-rated games face an under-18 ban and an adult off switch.

Published

on

On 11 November 2026 the European Commission published the Digital Fairness Act, a draft that names PEGI ratings as a way to treat a game as aimed at children. Paid loot boxes would be barred for anyone under 18, and every player would get a switch to turn them off.

Europe’s trade bodies say that pairing will shove teen-rated live games toward 18+ stickers, or force the random-reward shops out of the titles those players still use.

What the Digital Fairness Act Requires for Games

The draft, COM(2026) 1100, is a regulation. If it is agreed, it would apply directly in every Member State and repeal the 2005 Unfair Commercial Practices Directive. A minor is anyone under 18. Commissioner Michael McGrath called it the most significant reform of EU consumer protection rules in more than 20 years.

Games sit in a short run of articles on spending features. Article 14 covers paid-for virtual currencies. Article 15 covers paid-for variable reward systems, the legal label for loot boxes, card packs and other paid random drops. Article 16 bars pay-to-progress and pay-to-win buys for minors. None of that waits for a gambling licence. It is consumer law aimed at the shop inside the game.

THE GAMES RULES IN ARTICLES 14 TO 16

Rule Every player Players under 18
Paid virtual currencies Show the real-money value of items, in the currency used to buy the first virtual currency Currencies off by default, and switched on only with parent or guardian approval, when the product is directed at minors or the trader knows with reasonable certainty that minors use it
Paid loot boxes Disclose item types and odds, and offer an easy tool to disable the systems Must not be offered at all
Pay-to-progress and pay-to-win Not banned for adults Must not be offered

The draft also lets players turn off design that is meant, or can reasonably be foreseen, to push compulsive use, including login streaks and notifications that are not tied to something the player just did. Subscriptions would need a clear cancel path. Customer support would have to produce a human being on request. Those rules sit beside the loot-box clauses, and they would hit live-service stores even if a studio never sells a pack.

PEGI 16 Now Reads as a Kids Product

The commercial problem is how a studio proves who is 17. Articles on personalised ads and prices say traders do not have to process extra personal data to work out whether someone is a child. Recital 32 repeats the point: the rules should not push firms to hold, buy or process more personal data than they already have.

So the draft looks for other signals. Recital 29 says whether a product is directed at minors, or whether a trader knows with reasonable certainty that minors use it, should be judged from objective indicators. Recital 30 then names the Pan-European Game Information system, PEGI, alongside store age labels and account data a firm already holds. That is the second-order move. A rating built as guidance for parents becomes a legal clue that the product is a kids product, which is the test that turns Articles 14 to 16 on.

PEGI has already moved the sticker. On 12 March 2026 it said paid random items default to PEGI 16, and can be PEGI 18 for social casino games. New submissions have used those bands since June 2026. In October it began updating existing digital games to PEGI 16 where a title still sat at PEGI 3, 7 or 12 and sold loot boxes or card packs. Dirk Bosmans, director of PEGI, said older games that stay on sale should match current standards.

PEGI INTERACTIVE RISK BANDS FROM JUNE 2026

  • Paid random items: Card packs, gacha pulls and keys that hide the reward until after payment start at PEGI 16, and social casino games can be PEGI 18.
  • Time-limited paid offers: Battle-pass style shops with a clock or a stock cap start at PEGI 12, or PEGI 7 if spending controls are off by default.
  • Play-by-appointment: Daily quests that reward a return sit at PEGI 7, and rise to PEGI 12 if the game punishes a missed day.

EA Sports FC 27 now carries PEGI 16 because Football Ultimate Team sells paid random player packs. Earlier editions in the series, including EA Sports FC 25, sat at PEGI 3, with purchases handled as a notice rather than as the age number. Under the Digital Fairness Act, that new 16 is no longer only a shop warning. It is one of the indicators Brussels listed for a product directed at minors.

Andreas Lober, a partner at the law firm ADVANT Beiten, wrote that a game rated 18+ would face fewer of these limits than a game rated for all ages, and that developers might chase higher ratings as a result. The incentive is ugly and simple. Keep the packs by locking teens out, or keep the teens by killing the packs.

Europe’s Studios Call the Under-18 Line Unworkable

Video Games Europe and the European Games Developer Federation did not wait for a compromise draft. Their joint statement called the proposal unworkable, unjustified and disproportionate, and said it would leave millions of players with fewer games.

The text treats games rated below PEGI 18 as directed at children. Age ratings indicate suitability, not target audience. This risks imposing an 18+ threshold on almost all game features, which, in practice would force many games to refuse access to any under 18s at all.

Video Games Europe and the European Games Developer Federation, joint statement on the Digital Fairness Act

They add that the draft strips parents and teenagers of a say even when a parent would approve a purchase, and that PEGI is already used in 40 countries. PEGI, they note, spent this year widening its own tests for in-game purchases and paid random items, while the PEGI Code already asks for a clear real-world cost at the point virtual currency is bought. Console, PC and phone family tools can already block spend. The complaint is that Brussels is writing over a system it also plans to use as evidence.

Felix Falk, managing director of game, the German trade body, made the same point in plainer terms: long-running USK and PEGI marks would run empty if every title rated under 18 is treated as an offer for children. That is the trap hidden in recital 30. The industry built the rating to show a game was suitable at 12 or 16. The Act can read that same number as proof the audience includes children, which is enough to kill paid packs for anyone under 18.

Europe’s games business is not a handful of listed publishers. Video Games Europe says the region has 8,700 companies, most of them small studios. In 2024 the sector accounted for 116,000 jobs and €26.4 billion in revenue, with digital sales at 90 percent of that take. A rule that is painful for Ultimate Team is existential for a mid-size mobile live game whose shop is the product.

Belgium Cut FIFA Points, and Packs Survived

National gambling law already tried to do this job, and it did not travel. In April 2018 Belgium’s Gaming Commission treated paid loot boxes in FIFA 18, Overwatch and Counter-Strike: Global Offensive as illegal games of chance. Publishers faced fines of up to €800,000 and prison terms of up to five years, doubled where minors were involved. On 31 January 2019 Electronic Arts stopped selling FIFA Points in Belgium, which ended paid Ultimate Team packs there while leaving earned packs in the mode.

The Netherlands went after tradable rewards in the same period. A later penalty that reached €10 million against EA was set aside on 9 March 2022 by the country’s highest administrative court, which found the publisher had not broken Dutch games-of-chance law. Packs stayed in the build for most of Europe. Belgium remained the outlier that simply switched the currency shop off.

THE PATH FROM A NATIONAL BAN TO A UNION DRAFT

  1. April 2018: Belgium’s Gaming Commission rules that paid loot boxes in FIFA 18, Overwatch and CS:GO are illegal games of chance.
  2. 31 January 2019: EA stops selling FIFA Points in Belgium, cutting off paid Ultimate Team packs in that market.
  3. 9 March 2022: The Dutch high administrative court sets aside a penalty against EA that had reached €10 million.
  4. 12 March 2026: PEGI ties paid random items to a default PEGI 16 rating, with PEGI 18 for social casino games.
  5. June 2026: Newly submitted games are classified under the wider interactive-risk tests.
  6. October 2026: PEGI starts moving existing digital-only games with paid random items from PEGI 3, 7 or 12 up to PEGI 16.
  7. 11 November 2026: The Commission adopts the Digital Fairness Act proposal and lists PEGI among the indicators that a product is directed at minors.

The DFA does not ask whether a pack is a bet under criminal gambling law. It asks whether the product is aimed at children, then bans the paid random shop for them and hands every adult a disable tool. That is why a PEGI 16 football game is now a harder case than a PEGI 18 shooter. The rating that was meant to warn parents is the same rating that can pull the title into the kids chapter.

An Off Switch for Every Paid Loot Box

The minor ban is the headline. Article 15(2) is the clause publishers cannot isolate in a kids profile. Traders must give every consumer, in an easily accessible way, effective tools to disable paid-for variable reward systems. George Osborn, who runs the Video Games Industry Memo newsletter, put the commercial reading in one line aimed at EA Sports FC.

“EA might be looking at it and going, ‘This isn’t great news for [EA Sports FC] Ultimate Team because people can switch it off,’” Osborn said. He added that Ultimate Team is at least hived off in a box, so EA could age-gate the mode. A collectible card game whose paid random rewards are the premise has no such box. Turning the system off is turning the game off.

Osborn’s other fear is design gravity. If a company still wants the EU’s few hundred million consumers, it has to build the switch, the odds screen and the real-money price tag. Once those tools exist, a second version that hides them starts to look like a choice, not a technical limit. The Brussels Effect is the story most people will tell. The sharper pressure is local: a PEGI 16 live game that cannot tell a 16-year-old from a 19-year-old without new identity data, and an adult player who can kill the pack shop in settings.

Small free-to-play teams sit in the worst seat. They already lean on a thin paying slice. They rarely have a separate 18+ mode, a family-account stack or a legal bench to argue what “directed at minors” means when the store page still shows PEGI 12. The draft tries to avoid a new age database. The shortcut it chose, the rating on the box, is exactly what those games wear in public.

Pay-to-Win Could Cover Almost Any Purchase

Article 3(19) defines pay-to-progress and pay-to-win as in-game or in-app purchases that are necessary, or are presented as necessary, for progress or success, bought with real-money payments or with paid virtual currency. Article 16 then bans those mechanisms for minors where the product is directed at them or the trader knows with reasonable certainty that they use it.

PAY-TO-WIN AS THE DRAFT DEFINES IT

  • The legal hook: A buy that is needed, or sold as needed, to move forward or to win, not only a loot box.
  • The currency path: It counts if the player pays in money or in paid-for virtual currency.
  • The industry objection: Video Games Europe says the wording could cover almost any purchase in a game, and that no developer could be sure the design is legal with Commission fines in the background.

Lober flagged the mixed-age mess that follows. If adults may still buy power and children may not, a shared server becomes a two-class pitch. If the safe answer is to strip those buys for everyone, the live-service model that funds the client starts to look like a cosmetic catalogue. A battle pass that sells only looks, with a published euro price and no random drop, fits the draft more cleanly than a pack whose contents are the point.

That is why the Act can shrink random-reward shops without a gambling finding. It does not need to prove a pack is a slot machine. It needs a PEGI number, a reasonable-certainty test, and a definition of “necessary” wide enough that a season-pass XP boost starts to look like progress for sale. Studios that already sell known items at known prices have less to rebuild than studios whose loop is a roll.

A 6% Fine Sits Behind a Draft That Can Still Move

Enforcement is split on purpose. For large cross-border cases the Commission investigates itself, it may impose fines not exceeding 6% of worldwide annual turnover. National penalties must be able to reach at least 4% of turnover in the Member States concerned, or at least €2 million where turnover figures are missing. Video Games Europe cited the 6% figure as the reason fuzzy design rules are unacceptable. The number is a ceiling for the Commission’s own cases, not a standard ticket, but it is the number every live-ops lead will take to a publisher board.

The Commission’s consumer pitch is separate money. McGrath said unfair digital practices already cost people €10.3 billion a year. The newsroom note on the package says the Act is expected to save EU consumers up to €13.7 billion a year. About 60% of people in the bloc already buy goods or services online, and those shoppers are more than 60% more likely to hit problems than people who buy offline, according to the 2025 Consumer Conditions Scoreboard cited in that note. “We are not making it harder to do business. We are making it harder to do business unfairly,” McGrath said.

THE PACKAGE IN FOUR FIGURES

  • Europe’s studios: 8,700 companies, 116,000 jobs in 2024, €26.4 billion in revenue.
  • Claimed consumer save: up to €13.7 billion a year if the rules bite as modelled.
  • Current digital harm: €10.3 billion a year in losses McGrath tied to unfair online practices.
  • Commission fine cap: not more than 6% of worldwide annual turnover in the large cases Brussels takes itself.

Article 40 says the regulation would enter into force on the twentieth day after it appears in the Official Journal, and would apply from 12 months after that. None of that starts until the European Parliament and the Council agree a text, and both will be lobbied to narrow “directed at minors,” to honour PEGI as suitability rather than audience, and to put parents back on the virtual-currency switch. The industry has already offered a softer deal: purchases and chat off by default for children, a parent to switch them on, real-money prices, refunds on unused currency, and smaller top-ups.

Until that rewrite lands, the page that matters is recital 30. It puts PEGI in the kit for deciding that a game is aimed at children. For a PEGI 16 pack game, that is not a worldwide philosophy. It is a product decision: raise the rating, gut the shop, or build an identity stack the Act says it does not require.

Disclaimer: This article is news reporting and analysis of a European Commission proposal. It is informational only and is not legal advice, regulatory advice or guidance on how any studio, platform or publisher should design, rate or sell a game. Readers who need to act on the draft, including companies that sell into the EU, should consult a qualified EU consumer-law or games-regulatory lawyer before changing products, age gates or shops. Figures, article numbers and status details reflect the Commission text and public statements as published on 11 November 2026 and may change in Parliament, in the Council, or in later guidance.

Harry is the editor of COVER 365, an independent publication he owns and runs, and a journalist of ten years who moved from reporting into editing. Anything the site reviews has been used before it is judged. A phone, a car, a game or a piece of travel gear is tested in ordinary conditions, its measured results are set against the maker's specification sheet, and where the two disagree the article says which one to trust and why. No product gets a verdict Harry has not earned by using it. Off the test bench, the same rule of primary evidence applies: business stories come from filings and results, science from the published paper, sports from the governing body's records, and news from statements and transcripts rather than second hand accounts. Coverage runs across technology, auto, gaming, lifestyle and travel as well as news, business, science, sports and entertainment, for readers in every part of the world. Every figure is checked before publication and corrected publicly under a stated policy when wrong. Reader mail is answered at support@cover365.in.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending