Connect with us

NEWS

The Colts Need a First and Taylor Is the Price

Indianapolis is using Jonathan Taylor to replace a 2027 first-round pick already sent to the Jets, with a second-rounder as the working floor.

Published

on

The Indianapolis Colts are trying to turn Jonathan Taylor into a 2027 second-round pick before all trading ends at 4 p.m. New York time on Tuesday, November 10. They have no first-rounder of their own after last year’s Sauce Gardner deal, and a second is the working floor for the 27-year-old back they extended in August.

New York already put a second-round pick and a 2028 fifth on the table, then took it back. Late on November 9, Indianapolis signaled it would strongly consider that same package if it returned.

The Offer Indianapolis Already Turned Down

The Giants were the one club that put numbers in writing. Jay Glazer said New York offered a second-round pick and a fifth-round pick, then pulled the proposal. Dan Duggan noted the fifth had to be a 2028 choice because the Giants do not hold a 2027 fifth. Indianapolis said no. Glazer’s reading was that a Taylor deal then looked unlikely unless the Colts came down.

Overnight, the posture flipped. Jordan Schultz said Indianapolis would “strongly consider” a similar package if New York put it back, and added, “My understanding is that he’s open to be traded.” Schultz went further: “In fact, I think he’d welcome a fresh start at this point.” Taylor has not filed a formal trade request. After a 27-23 home loss to Dallas on November 8, he said he was unsure of his future in the city where he has played since 2020.

A general manager told Jason La Canfora the Colts would probably move Taylor for a second. That is the tension of the last 48 hours. Indianapolis wanted a first-round equivalent. The only documented bid was a second and a future fifth, and the bidder walked.

THE TAYLOR MARKET, HOUR BY HOUR

  1. November 8, morning: Josina Anderson says the Giants have cooled on Taylor because of price and may have closed the door.
  2. November 8, afternoon: Glazer reports the second-and-fifth offer is off the table unless Indianapolis comes down.
  3. November 8, night: Giants coach John Harbaugh does not refute the pulled offer and says nothing is imminent.
  4. November 9, 11:17 p.m.: Schultz says the Colts would strongly consider that last Giants package if it came back, and that Taylor would welcome a fresh start.
  5. November 10, 4:00 p.m. New York: League trading for 2026 closes.

Other clubs have checked in without matching that paper. The Vikings, Packers, Bengals, Chiefs, Broncos and Seahawks have all been connected to Taylor. La Canfora was told Denver’s name by an executive, then Troy Renck said the asking price points to the Broncos standing down while still monitoring. Jonah Coleman’s recent play and RJ Harvey’s stay on injured reserve give Denver a reason not to spend a second. Green Bay has been linked as Josh Jacobs’ situation has gotten messier, but no Packers bid has been described in the same detail as New York’s.

A second-round pick only pays if the buyer already wins the line of scrimmage. Greg Olsen made that point on the Giants’ broadcast, and it tracks with what New York just showed against Philadelphia: no push up front, an interior that lost consistently, and a run game no imported back was going to save in that spot. That is a clean reason for a club to pull a 2nd-and-5th and wait.

A Second-Rounder Has to Replace a First

The reason a second-round pick is being treated like a first is simple. On November 4, 2025, Indianapolis sent its 2026 first-rounder, its 2027 first-rounder and wide receiver Adonai Mitchell to the New York Jets for Gardner. The 2026 choice became pick No. 16, used on Kenyon Sadiq. The 2027 choice still sits with the Jets, and with the Colts at 2-7 it has been tracking inside the top 10.

Chris Ballard, in his 10th season, was fired general manager Chris Ballard on October 19 after a 26-20 home loss to the winless Titans dropped Indianapolis to 2-4. Owner Carlie Irsay-Gordon said the sense of urgency had never been higher. Assistant GM Ed Dodds is running personnel through the deadline. Coach Shane Steichen still reports to ownership.

Making this change during the season was a deliberate decision. Waiting would only delay the important work that needs to begin now.

Carlie Irsay-Gordon, Colts owner, team statement, October 19, 2026

Eight days later the club moved two captains. Quenton Nelson went to Seattle on October 27 for a 2027 third-round pick and a 2028 fifth. DeForest Buckner went to San Francisco on October 28 for a 2027 fourth. The Indianapolis future draft pick ledger now shows volume without a first-rounder.

COLTS 2027 DRAFT INVENTORY

Round Picks Origin
First 0 Traded to the Jets for Gardner
Second 1 Colts’ own choice
Third 2 Own pick plus Seattle (Nelson)
Fourth 2 Own pick plus San Francisco (Buckner)
Fifth 1 Colts’ own choice
Sixth 0 Sent to Buffalo in the Van Pran-Granger deal
Seventh 2 Own pick plus Buffalo

That is eight selections and no seat in Round 1. Compensatory math could push the pile toward 10 in the spring, still without a first. A high second for Taylor would become the earliest pick this front office controls in April. Irsay-Gordon has been described as motivated to move. The Jets, holding that 2027 first, are the silent party in every Indianapolis loss.

What a New Team Would Owe Jonathan Taylor

Taylor signed a two-year, $44 million extension on August 6 that runs through 2028, at $22 million per year, with $39 million in total guarantees and a $15 million signing bonus. Over The Cap’s year-by-year Taylor contract figures put his 2026 cap charge at $16,187,000, his 2027 charge at $21,020,000 and his 2028 charge at $22,980,000. The 2027 base salary is $15 million. It becomes fully guaranteed on February 25, the fifth day of the waiver period. 2027 cash due is $16,020,000. 2028 cash due is $17,980,000, including a $7.5 million roster bonus.

Jason Fitzgerald of Over The Cap has the remainder of 2026, for a club that trades for him now, at about $4.4 million plus up to $1 million in incentives. The 2027 money is still an option until late February. A team that spends a second-round pick is still making a 2027 plan, not booking a two-month rental.

TAYLOR’S LAST THREE SEASONS

  • 2024: 14 games, 303 carries, 1,431 yards, 11 rushing touchdowns.
  • 2025: 17 games, 323 carries, 1,585 yards, 18 rushing touchdowns, 46 catches.
  • 2026: 7 games, 148 carries, 610 yards, 4.1 per carry, 8 rushing touchdowns, 21 catches for 202 yards.

He is the 2021 rushing champion, a 2020 second-round pick at No. 41, and a three-time Pro Bowler. The 2026 line is down from the last two years, and the offensive line in front of him is not the one that blocked for 1,585 yards. He turns 28 in January. That age, plus the February guarantee, is why a second-round pick is both the floor and, so far, the ceiling.

Tom Pelissero said no team had come close to a first-round equivalent, and that Indianapolis has viewed Taylor as part of a rebuild even while listening. The club told Daniel Jones on Saturday it would not trade him. Taylor is the star they are willing to move. Jones is not.

The Corner Indianapolis Cannot Move

A high-ranking executive told La Canfora the Colts “want to move a corner.” The two names are Gardner, 25, and Charvarius Ward, 30. Wanting it and doing it are different jobs.

Gardner is in a four-year, $120.4 million extension that runs through 2030. His 2026 cap hit is $9.5 million. His 2027 guarantee is $24.95 million. Trading him this year would dump more than $45 million in dead money on Indianapolis, a defender-record figure that a rebuilding club can barely pretend to absorb. He has missed time with calf injuries since the Jets deal and has not been the difference those two first-round picks were supposed to buy.

He also wants to stay. Asked if he wanted to remain a Colt, Gardner said yes.

Oh yes, for sure. I embrace everything. I feel like I’m fit for a rebuild, anything. It don’t matter what it is.

Sauce Gardner, Colts cornerback

Ward is on a three-year, $54 million deal paying a $12.98 million base this season, with roughly $7 million left. No 2027 money is guaranteed. He thought about retirement after three concussions in 2025. To get a pick of any size, Indianapolis may have to eat part of that remaining 2026 salary. Jonathan Jones has said the Colts are not paying down contracts to purchase draft choices. Buyers take the full deal. That rule, if it holds, all but ends a Gardner trade and puts a tax on Ward.

Last November 4, Indianapolis was 7-2 and buying. This November 10 it is 2-7 and trying to sell the player it bought, except the contract does not move. Taylor is the liquid asset. Gardner is the bill.

Josh Downs Wants Out on a Rookie Deal

The rest of the roster is easier to shop and harder to price. Josh Downs, in the last year of his 2023 third-round rookie contract, has asked for a trade. Clubs were already calling before he asked. Indianapolis has a fourth-round offer on the table and has told teams it wants more than that. Downs is a rental. Brian Thomas Jr., by comparison, has two years left on a first-round deal, which is one reason some AFC clubs are calling Indianapolis instead of waiting on Jacksonville.

Keenan Allen, 34, is a six-time Pro Bowler on a $1.3 million base. He is the cleanest chip on the board, a post-deadline cut candidate if nobody bids, though a cut after 4 p.m. would send him to waivers. Grover Stewart has drawn calls. The pattern so far is that Indianapolis has only moved players in the last year of a deal, Nelson and Buckner among them. Downs fits that pattern. Taylor, signed through 2028, does not, which is why his price keeps sticking.

STILL ON THE SHELF

  • Josh Downs: Walk-year slot receiver who requested a trade; a fourth-round bid is in, and the club wants an extra asset on top.
  • Keenan Allen: Age-34 veteran on a $1.3 million base, the cheapest proven target on the roster.
  • Charvarius Ward: 30-year-old starter with no 2027 guarantee and about $7 million of 2026 salary still to be paid.
  • Sauce Gardner: 25, under contract through 2030, more than $45 million in dead money if he is moved this year.

Downs is the one who asked to leave. Gardner is the one who asked to stay. Taylor sits in the middle, extended in August, unsure in November, and worth more to a contender than anyone else Indianapolis can still deal.

Four Picks for McCaffrey, One Second for Taylor

The comparison Indianapolis has floated is Carolina’s October 2022 trade of Christian McCaffrey. San Francisco sent second, third, fourth and fifth-round picks, the first three in 2023 and the fifth in 2024, beating out the Rams and Bills. McCaffrey was 26, a more complete receiver, and cheaper in-year for the 49ers, who owed him $690,000 for the rest of 2022. Carolina had been asking for first-round capital and took a four-pick Day 2 pile instead.

Taylor is a year older than McCaffrey was then, with more career carries and a larger remaining guarantee. He is still producing, 8 rushing touchdowns in 7 games, but he is not a clone of that deal. A second-round pick plus a later choice is the package that has actually appeared. A 2/3/4/5 return has not. Holding out for McCaffrey money is how a club watches a deadline pass with the same back, the same 2-7 record, and the same hole in Round 1.

Pelissero’s warning is the offseason market. If Taylor stays, more backs will be available in March, and the desperation that makes a contender spend a second in November will be gone. Jonathan Jones has argued the other side: keep him into December, suffer another injury, and the one path to an early 2027 pick closes. Both can be true. The February guarantee is the lever that lets Indianapolis wait. The missing first-round pick is the reason waiting is expensive.

The Clock Stops at 4 p.m. in New York

WHAT WE KNOW

  • The cutoff: All 2026 trading ends at 4:00 p.m. New York time on Tuesday, November 10. The next window opens March 11, 2027.
  • The paper bid: The Giants offered a second-round pick and a 2028 fifth, Indianapolis rejected it, New York pulled it, and the Colts later said they would strongly consider that package if it returned.
  • The cap math: A new team would owe about $4.4 million for the rest of 2026, with Taylor’s $15 million 2027 base unvested until February 25.
  • The first-round hole: Indianapolis already sent 2026 and 2027 firsts to the Jets for Gardner and has only moved Nelson and Buckner for a third, a fourth and a 2028 fifth.

WHAT IS UNCONFIRMED

  • A live Giants bid: Whether New York will put the second-and-fifth back on the table, or strip the fifth now that Indianapolis has blinked.
  • A completed Taylor trade: No deal has been announced, even as morning reports said the Colts were expected to take the best offer they get.
  • A corner moving: Gardner’s dead money and Ward’s remaining salary have not produced a documented bid that fits the club’s no-pay-down rule.

Irsay-Gordon told the building in October that waiting would only delay the work. Nelson and Buckner are already gone. Taylor is the remaining piece who can actually buy an early 2027 pick, and the documented price is the second-rounder Indianapolis does not yet have. At 4 p.m. in New York the phones go quiet, and the first-round choice the Colts spent on Gardner stays in New Jersey either way.

Harry is the editor of COVER 365, an independent publication he owns and runs, and a journalist of ten years who moved from reporting into editing. Anything the site reviews has been used before it is judged. A phone, a car, a game or a piece of travel gear is tested in ordinary conditions, its measured results are set against the maker's specification sheet, and where the two disagree the article says which one to trust and why. No product gets a verdict Harry has not earned by using it. Off the test bench, the same rule of primary evidence applies: business stories come from filings and results, science from the published paper, sports from the governing body's records, and news from statements and transcripts rather than second hand accounts. Coverage runs across technology, auto, gaming, lifestyle and travel as well as news, business, science, sports and entertainment, for readers in every part of the world. Every figure is checked before publication and corrected publicly under a stated policy when wrong. Reader mail is answered at support@cover365.in.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending